I realize I write certain things, attempt certain genres, not because I have a story that can only be told in that way but because I want to challenge myself to write that way. I want to have a go at making someone scared as they read, or feel emotional pain, or joy.
I assume that is the purpose of any writing, to have an emotional reaction on the part of the reader. I think in my way I need to break it down and see things more as genre instead of as all encompassing.
I can only be scary in a horror piece. I can only be romantic in a love story. I can only have action in a fantasy novel.
It's hard to parse that kind of thinking and make it integral to my writing as a whole. Writing a piece that has all the elements of the separate genres and in turn can't fall into one specifically.
I think in that way a piece of writing will be too stark in ideas to be coherent as a story. You need to take one or two elements that are prominent in a certain genre so that a combination of which is still digestible and not just a mishmash of ideas.
Finding this road in my own writing is hard. My best pieces deal heavily in depression, and the way people act or feel in that state. There aren't elements of horror, elation or even love. It's simply a dark glimpse.
To find a way to place one of my prominent characters inside an existential horror full of suspense, a yearning to find love in a dark place as a means of salvation and the actions needed to achieve that are extremely hard to put together.
I think for me though being able to write something that is suspenseful and not just emotional or tense and not just dark is the real dig.
I use these exercises in writing different genre tropes to tease out those elements, become familiar with them, enhance them and ultimately, if things go well, add them to future projects even if just in pieces.
I haven't been that successful yet, having only a few attempts under my sleeve. Writing suspense effectively and getting a real sense of horror or terror on the sheet seems elusive. I hope that in analyzing other work, exposing myself to experiences and trying my best to pen them out will lead to a level of success.
I can only try.